|
If you take a snap shot view of the last
50 years, it is interesting to observe cattle breeding trends and the
traits that have been generally selected for by cattle breeders during
each time period. In the 50’s and early 60’s it was for small-framed
cattle. In the early 70’s and on into the 80’s the frame race was on
and the emphasis was on lean beef. In the 90’s through the present
time, the focus has been on carcass quality traits. With the rise to
prominence of branded products, in particular of Certified Angus Beef,
we have been and still are in the black craze phase.
The black craze phase is continuing to
influence breeding decisions today. Several breeds that could easily
change the hide color of their cattle to black have done so with at
least a portion of the breed. This emphasis on changing hide color to
black has been done in an effort to try to receive a premium in the
market place. Unfortunately, color has seemingly been the primary trait
of focus rather than selecting for traits that actually effect
production costs, product quality and producer profitability.
In each of the
production phases the industry has been through, and with the current
black craze phase, cattle breeders have been seeking to meet a market
demand. In an effort to meet this market demand, many cattle producers
have emphasized selection for single traits such as color that have
relatively minimal impact on true profitable beef production in a range
environment. This single trait selection emphasis on color has often
been done at the sacrifice of other traits such as the Six Essential
traits of disposition, fertility, weight, conformation, hardiness and
milk production. These are the traits that truly have tremendous affects
on production costs and profitability for the cow-calf producer. |
It is important to remember that the
majority of the breeds of cattle that we have in the United States today
originally came from unique climatic regions of the world and were
selected for specific traits based on the needs and lifestyles of the
people there. As a result, we have breeds of cattle today that were
originally bred in extremely different climates and designed for
specific purposes. When one looks at the vast climate differences that
are present in the United States, it is not only acceptable, but also
necessary that we have distinct and different types of breeds of
cattle. The type of cattle that best performs in the environment of
Whitefish, Montana will be different from the type of cattle that will
be best adapted to the environment at Okeechobee, Florida. While one
might be able to take cattle from Okeechobee, Florida to Whitefish,
Montana or vice versa and have them survive, the environments are so
different that neither group of adapted cattle will perform as well as
they would in their original environment without significant assistance
and supplementation.
Cattle that perform
the best in a specific climatic environment will be from those breeds
and breeders who have selected for productive traits in a similar type
environment. Taking a trait, such as a black hide color, and forcing it
into a breeding program in a climate where a black hide is actually a
disadvantage to cattle performance is at best questionable. Changing
hide color to black, in the short term, may result in cattle that are
more appealing to a certain group of buyers. However, it will not
automatically change the quality of product that animal produces.
Selecting for carcass traits based on their economic importance when
combined with the Six Essential traits, is a genetically superior plan
as it is highly doubtful one will ever ask a waiter for “a black hide,
cooked medium rare.”
|